Best Online Printing Services and How to Tell Them Apart
Every online printer calls itself the best. Judge them on the things you can check before you pay: named paper stocks, color control, the proof you get, who looks at your file, the finishes on offer and when the clock starts.
The best online printing service for your job names its stocks by weight, profiles its color, offers a proof before press, has a person check your file and counts turnaround from approval. Match the printer to the job, then test it with free paper samples and one small run, such as 100 standard business cards for $17.57, before you place the big order.
Quick tips
Sort the printer by the job, then test it small
No single printer wins every job. A shop built for runs of cards and flyers is a different business from one built for signs or boxes. Decide what you print most, shortlist the printers that fit, and let a sample pack and a small order settle the rest.
Watch it printed
See standard business cards made, in 167 seconds
What separates a good online printer from a busy one
Two printers can show the same card photo and ship very different cards. The difference sits in details the order page either lists or hides. Read the page before you read the reviews.
- Paper stocks, by weight and finish. 14pt gloss, 16pt uncoated with soft touch and 18pt premium white linen are three different cards. A page that only says card stock leaves you guessing.
- Color control. Look for a named standard. 4OVER4 uses G7 color profiling with multi-day accuracy tests.
- Proofing. You should be able to choose between going straight to production, a free online proof and a hard copy proof.
- File checks. A person should review resolution, bleed and color mode before press. Every 4OVER4 order includes a free file check.
- Finishing. Spot UV, foil stamping, embossing, soft touch and rounded corners in the configurator, priced, not quote only.
- Turnaround and support. Days counted from approval, and a phone number a real person answers.
The seven checks in our guide on how to choose a commercial printing company go deeper on each one, with the questions to ask a sales rep.
Which kind of printer fits which job
Online printers specialize, even when their menus look alike. A commercial printer built around business cards, postcards, flyers and brochures runs those products all day, which is where its prices and turnaround are strongest. A large format shop earns its keep on banners, posters and signs. A packaging printer handles boxes and labels with dielines. A print broker takes your order and sends it to someone else, which our guide on what a print broker is explains.
Pick the kind that matches most of your spend, not your one odd job. If you order cards, postcards and brochures every quarter, a commercial printer with 60+ paper stocks and 1,000+ products lets one account cover them all, so the logo on the card matches the logo on the brochure. For direct mail, the head to head in postcard printing services compared shows what to check on a mailing job.
Options beyond the big consumer design sites
The biggest consumer printing sites are built for a first order: a template, a default stock and a checkout. That works for a one off. It gets expensive and limiting once you order the same pieces every month, or you want a stock heavier than the default.
Compare the ladder at the quantity you buy, not the headline price. At 4OVER4.COM, 500 standard business cards cost $36.26 and 1,000 cost $65.91, standard postcards run 1,000 for $86.78 at the smallest 2.5 by 2.5 inch size, and soft touch postcards come on 32pt to 80pt uncoated stock for the card people keep. Our printer alternatives hub lines up 4OVER4 against the brands buyers switch from, product by product, so you can check the claims on the pieces you order.
Proofs, file checks and color you can reorder
The proof is where a good printer earns its reputation. At 4OVER4 you choose one of three paths on products such as business cards and postcards: straight to production when the file is proven, a free online proof that shows the trim line and your art at full size, or a next day hardcopy proof when the stock or the color is new to you.
Behind the proof, experts review every artwork against a 30-point checklist, and the press runs on G7 color profiling, so a reorder next quarter matches the first run. Keep your approved file on the account and reorder from it rather than uploading a new export, which is a common reason a second run looks different.
Turnaround, shipping and a person on the phone
Turnaround means production days after approval, plus transit. Standard business cards, postcards and flyers take 3 business days at 4OVER4, standard posters 5, and many products offer faster options down to same day when the proof is approved by noon ET. The numbers that tell you whether a printer keeps its dates are on time delivery and early shipping: ours are 99.8 percent on time and 82 percent early.
Shipping is a real line on every retail order, so compare the delivered cost, not the print price alone. Then test support before you need it. Call 718-932-2700 or text the same number, and a person picks up, which matters the day a file needs a fix an hour before cutoff.
Test a printer with a small order before the big one
A sample pack and one small run tell you more than any review. Start with free paper samples, which ship free, and hold the stocks you are considering in your hand. Then place the smallest real order you would use anyway.
What to check when the box arrives:
- Color against your proof. Compare a brand color with the proof you approved, in daylight.
- Trim and corners. Look at the edges of ten cards from different parts of the stack.
- Stock weight. Match the card to the sample you liked.
- Packing and date. Note the ship date against the promise, and how the box protected the corners.
A first run of 100 standard business cards plus 50 small postcards costs less than a lunch meeting. For the full vetting list, see how to choose an online print service.
Wally tests the printer before the big order
Samples first, then one small run
Wally never picks a printer from a banner ad. He orders free paper samples, which ship free, then 100 standard business cards for $17.57, and checks the color against his proof, the trim on ten cards and the ship date. When all three pass, the big run goes to the same printer.
Order free samples →
Job by job
The right kind of online printer for each job
Find the job you order most. The 4OVER4 column uses live configurator prices and standard turnaround from the approved proof.
| Your job | Kind of printer | What to look for | At 4OVER4 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Business cards every quarter | Commercial online printer | Named stocks, finishes, reorder from file | 500 standard cards for $36.26, 3 business days |
| A direct mail postcard campaign | Commercial printer with mailing sizes | Heavy cover stock, proof, even color | 1,000 postcards for $86.78 at 2.5 x 2.5 in, 3 business days |
| A premium card with a tactile finish | Printer with finishing in house | Soft touch, spot UV, foil priced online | Soft touch postcards on 32pt to 80pt stock |
| Brochures and flyers for a launch | Commercial online printer | A half fold and text weights | Brochures from 50 for $57.11, 3 business days |
| Event posters and signs | Large format capable printer | Sizes, weatherproof stocks | Standard posters from 50 for $108.75, 5 business days |
Specs and pricing
Standard business card specs and pricing
The live sizes, stocks and quantity ladder for standard business cards, the small order most buyers use to test a new printer.
| Quantity | Price Per Unit | Total |
|---|---|---|
| 100 | 17.6¢ | $17.57 |
| 200 | 11.5¢ | $23.07 |
| 300 | 9.15¢ | $27.46 |
| 400 | 7.96¢ | $31.86 |
| 500 | 7.25¢ | $36.26 |
| 600 | 6.77¢ | $40.64 |
| 700 | 6.43¢ | $45.04 |
| 800 | 6.18¢ | $49.43 |
Print it
Three pieces to test a printer on
Ready-made layouts
Blank business card templates for a test order
Start from a blank at the exact trim size with the bleed and safe zone marked, so the test order measures the printer and not the file.
See it in use
Business cards customers have printed
%22%2F%3E%3Ccircle%20cx%3D%2240%22%20cy%3D%2249%22%20r%3D%2225%22%20fill%3D%22%232dd4bf%22%20opacity%3D%220.15%22%2F%3E%3Ccircle%20cx%3D%2278%22%20cy%3D%2258%22%20r%3D%2214%22%20fill%3D%22%232dd4bf%22%20opacity%3D%220.1%22%2F%3E%3Crect%20x%3D%2270%22%20y%3D%2228%22%20width%3D%2225%22%20height%3D%2234%22%20rx%3D%224%22%20fill%3D%22%232dd4bf%22%20opacity%3D%220.08%22%20transform%3D%22rotate(35%2080%2030)%22%2F%3E%3C%2Fsvg%3E)
Explore more
Where to go next
By the numbers
What to check on any printer, in numbers
Common Questions
Comparing online printers, answered
How can I tell a good online printer from a cheap one before I order?
Read the order page. A good printer names each stock by weight and finish, states a color standard, lets you choose a proof, has a person check your file and counts turnaround from approval. If any of those are missing, ask support before you pay, and then run a small test order.
Are the big consumer printing sites cheaper?
Sometimes on the first order, less often on the reorder. Compare the price at the quantity you buy, on the stock you want, delivered. The alternatives hub compares us product by product with the brands buyers switch from.
Can I feel the paper before I order?
Yes. Free samples ship free from 4OVER4, so you can hold 14pt gloss, 16pt uncoated with soft touch, linen and metallic pearl stocks side by side before you choose. A sample pack settles most stock questions faster than a product photo.
Which proof option should I pick on a first order?
Choose the free online proof. It shows your art at full size with the trim line marked, so you can catch a typo or a margin problem before press. Pick the next day hardcopy proof when the exact color on a new stock matters, and go straight to production only on a file you have printed before.
How do I keep color the same from one order to the next?
Reorder from the same approved file instead of exporting a new one, and stay with the same stock and finish. 4OVER4 runs G7 color profiling with multi-day accuracy tests, which keeps a repeat run close to the first.
What happens if an order arrives wrong?
Contact support with photos and your order number, by phone or text on 718-932-2700. 4OVER4 backs orders with five guarantees together: quality, price match, on time every time, customer service and ultimate satisfaction, all set out on the guarantees page.
Get Started
Put one printer to the test this week
Order free paper samples, run 100 standard business cards, and judge 4OVER4.COM on the color, the trim and the date before you move the big order.
Legal Disclaimer
Gold Standard guarantees apply to all standard orders placed through 4over4.com. Price match requires verifiable proof of a competitor's published price for an equivalent product with matching specifications and turnaround time. Satisfaction guarantee covers manufacturing defects and print quality issues. Contact support with order number and documentation.
